SG
chevron_right
Primary 5
chevron_right
Number and Algebra
Please help!p3math
Replies
3
Tricia Tan
6 years ago
Christina Goh
Tks
6 years ago
Tricia Tan
U welcome
6 years ago
Tricia Tan
U welcome
6 years ago
Alex R. S. Chia
Asked 9 years ago
SG
chevron_right
Primary 5
chevron_right
Number and Algebra
P5 question. Looking for a method that does not use algebra. Answer is $442.
Replies
14
BA Poh Ann
7 watches and 7 bags (7 sets) cost $1547.
1 watch and 1 bag (1 set) = $1547 ÷ 7 = $221
2 watches and 2 bags (2 sets) = $221 x 2 = $442
6 years ago
Sofie Krista
6 years ago
Hwee Koon
Or using simultaneous
12 watches n 20 handbags cost $3660
12 watches n 6 handbags cost $1896
14 handbags cost $3660-1896=1664
I handbags cost 1764/14=126
You are using algebra though. You've used the words 'watches' and 'handbags' instead of variables. You've used the algebraic property of distribution and solved equations as well. All these are algebraic properties. They may be disguised but you are using algebra.
6 years ago
Shaoyang Brandon
So, you mean...algebraic reasoning.
6 years ago
Maggie Lukes
Yes, that is what I mean. You are using algebraic reasoning.
6 years ago
Vanessa Wong
Actually Shaoyang Brandon did it appropriately by grouping them into groups of 7 with 1 watch and 1 bag in one group. Not so much of simultaneous equations here.
6 years ago
Maggie Lukes
It's still algebra!
6 years ago
Vanessa Wong
Well, the thing is it is easily understood by a primary school kid. He is not using variable x and y or something abstract.
6 years ago
Maggie Lukes
I realize that. But the question needs to be carefully crafted to make the numbers work out easily. It is easily accessible to youngsters, but the aim is to start algebraic thought.
6 years ago
Hariani Salleh
This heuristic is called the set method or restating the problem. In fact, if you look at some lower primary questions (which are NO LONGER in syllabus), they use symbolic representation to represent a number. E.g. ♤ + ♡ = 7, ♤ + ♤ = 4...
6 years ago
Monica Toh
Shaoyang Brandon ...U are correct because this is how the primary school teacher teach to get the answer for this type of question.
6 years ago
Alex R. S. Chia
Thank you everyone for the solution as well as the discussion 😄👍🏼
6 years ago
Maggie Lukes
You are using algebra though. You've used the words 'watches' and 'handbags' instead of variables. You've used the algebraic property of distribution and solved equations as well. All these are algebraic properties. They may be disguised but you are using algebra.
6 years ago
Shaoyang Brandon
So, you mean...algebraic reasoning.
6 years ago
Maggie Lukes
Yes, that is what I mean. You are using algebraic reasoning.
6 years ago
Maggie Lukes
It's still algebra!
6 years ago
Vanessa Wong
Well, the thing is it is easily understood by a primary school kid. He is not using variable x and y or something abstract.
6 years ago
Maggie Lukes
I realize that. But the question needs to be carefully crafted to make the numbers work out easily. It is easily accessible to youngsters, but the aim is to start algebraic thought.
6 years ago
Elvira Ho
Asked 9 years ago
SG
chevron_right
Primary 6
chevron_right
Number and Algebra
Can help?
Replies
1
Shaoyang Brandon
Hi, Elvira Ho. Refer to the image below for the solution to part a and b.
For part b, I leave it to you to complete the remaining steps to find the total oranges in the end. You should have an answer between 400 to 500. :)
6 years ago
Adrian Ng
Asked 9 years ago
SG
chevron_right
Primary 4
chevron_right
Number and Algebra